The most tantalizing will they/won’t they of the college football world (other than Lane Kiffin/Nick Saban’s whole deal) has finally been answered: The College Football Playoff is expanding to 12 teams starting in 2024.
This is objectively awesome and everyone should be happy about it.
There are several reasons for this but I’ll start with the one that will surely make the haters furious:
One of the most common critiques of expanding the playoff is that allowing more teams to advance makes the regular season less meaningful.
To that I'd like to ask if you even watched the last week of the 2022 season. A total of 63 games were played, and, according to odds available on FanDuel, only six of those games involved teams with any plausible shot at making the CFP. More than 90% of the games were essentially meaningless!
On the flip side, the new playoff will feature the six highest-ranked conference winners (which accounts for at least one mid-major making the field every season) in addition to the six highest-ranked teams. This means conference championship games will have way greater stakes. If a favored team loses, they’ll have to take one of the at-large spots, bumping another team out of the playoff. Top teams will be clawing tooth and nail for the top four spots to secure a bye. In addition, the teams ranked 5-8 will get to host a home game, which is another very big advantage worth playing for.
The real fun, of course will be the discussion about who gets the final spots every year. Since its inception in 2014, only 13 different schools have appeared in the CFP. Six teams have made multiple appearances. Rather than constantly discussing whether the same huge programs will be in the field every year, the new playoff discussion will hugely broaden the scope of programs discussed every year.
Six years ago, Christian McCaffrey made waves when he announced he was opting not to play in Stanford’s bowl game in order to focus on preparing for the NFL draft. Since then, the practice has become so commonplace among star players, it’s much more of a surprise if they do decide to play in a meaningless bowl game.
An expanded college football playoff is really the only way to combat this trend.
More teams being in contention for a national championship means more star players will have the motivation to compete in the postseason. This can only be a good thing for fans of the sport.
If a 12-team playoff was implemented this season, here are the teams that would be involved in the first-round games (according to the latest playoff rankings):
#12 Tulane @ #5 Ohio State
#11 Utah @ #6 Alabama
#10 Kansas State @ #7 Tennessee
#9 Clemson @ #8 Penn State
(Although Washington is currently ranked No. 12, Tulane would get the spot as the projected winner of the AAC. This, in my opinion, is awesome.)
Who’s saying no to this? A home playoff environment in Columbus, Tuscaloosa, Knoxville, and State College on the same weekend — yeah, I guess I could watch that.
Past iterations of the postseason have always stacked the deck against smaller schools, with many teams going undefeated during the regular season but never coming close to sniffing a playoff spot. What the new playoff allows for is a sort of guaranteed meaningful David vs. Goliath playoff matchup every year.
If you're sick of watching the same teams compete in the playoff, this really is the perfect fix. Each of the projected matchups in the new playoff format — between mostly large schools with passionate fanbases — have only been played one time. Unfamiliarity makes for erratic betting lines and fantastic games!
But beyond amazing atmospheres, more meaningful games, better motivation for players to compete, and must-watch college football for an extra month of the year, I guess I do see how the new playoff system is bad.
Photo by Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images